Antenna Modelling and Analysing Software
Preface
This website shall give newbies to antenna modelling an overview on the most frequently used programs.
But I also show a few details that are essential for a deeper understanding and correct judging of antenna
models setup and properties verification that are not included in everybodies standard repertoire.
The big 3 in ham antenna modelling software are EZNEC, 4nec2 and MMANA-GAL. Apart from these there are
YO, AO and also NECWin Plus, NEC2GO.
There are other, non nec or mininec kernel based programs. And other EM (electromagnetic modelling) software
based on ‘mesh engines’ such as FEKO EM, Ansys HFSS, Sonnet EM which do cost a pretty buck.
It must be mentioned that the commercially discontinued Antenna / Yagi Optimizer AO resp. YO by K6STI due
to its features handling tappered wires, wires meeting at angles and optimiser is a (not existing any more) option
to which many designers who have it stick to. AO/YO are commerially discontinued.
How many radio enthusiasts have been looking up this website since Jan. 2016?
Frontends to the solving engine: In general about EZNEC, 4nec2, MMANA and others
This chapter is written with a programmers view (I do industrial programming for 6 years now to earn my living).
But I find this approach quite useful to understand how the issued software works, which is the first step to
improved handling of such.
Antenna modelling software based on nec2, nec4, mininec kernels is a frontend to the named kernel.
We could say these softwares are ‘User Interfaces’ that handle a data set, namely an antenna geometrie and a command
to compute something to the kernel, which does the real work. Finally they handle the kernels output into charts or plots
when the calculation are done.
This is why for instance 4nec2 and EZNEC show the least of marginal aberration when we compare pattern or Return Loss plot output.
Provided both run same setting and kernels, like option ‘Use Extended Thin wire Kernel…’ (in the nec cards this is line ‘EK’.
Which by standard is ‘turned on’ in both EZNEC and 4nec2. Only when opting for the Standard Thin Wire Kernel the ‘EK’ line is added to the nec wires card
Here is a useful report about the ‘Thin wire Kernels’, yet again by L. B. Cebik, W4RNL 
The kernel is fed with the geometry of an antenna design. In a strictly formatted table.
As the kernel is programmed in Fortran and needs to be fed with commands and parameters according the nec cards
description in the NEC Manual. It is the frontends task to provide a useful interface like a table calculation like
geometry input or a geometry orientated editor and transform this into the NEC Cards tables before feeding the kernel.
It is understood that the genius of computing the antenna properties lies at the employees of the Lawrence Livermoore
Laboratories that coded the NEC Kernels. But it is also understood that the genuis of providing a convenient human machine
interface lies at the makers of said antenna modelling software. As before that punchcards needed to be produced and
fed to crude computation machines. That is why NEC Cards are called NEC Cards. Because in the beginning they were
hard paper punchcards.
Frontends to the solving engine: In general about EZNEC, 4nec2, MMANA and others
This chapter is written with a programmers view (I do industrial programming for 6 years now to earn my living).
But I find this approach quite useful to understand how the issued software works, which is the first step to
improved handling of such.
Antenna modelling software based on nec2, nec4, mininec kernels is a frontend to the named kernel.
We could say these softwares are ‘User Interfaces’ that handle a data set, namely an antenna geometrie and a command
to compute something to the kernel, which does the real work. Finally they handle the kernels output into charts or plots
when the calculation are done.
This is why for instance 4nec2 and EZNEC show the least of marginal aberration when we compare pattern or Return Loss plot output.
Provided both run same setting and kernels, like option ‘Use Extended Thin wire Kernel…’ (in the nec cards this is line ‘EK’.
Which by standard is ‘turned on’ in both EZNEC and 4nec2. Only when opting for the Standard Thin Wire Kernel the ‘EK’ line is added to the nec wires card
Here is a useful report about the ‘Thin wire Kernels’, yet again by L. B. Cebik, W4RNL
The kernel is fed with the geometry of an antenna design. In a strictly formatted table.
As the kernel is programmed in Fortran and needs to be fed with commands and parameters according the nec cards
description in the NEC Manual. It is the frontends task to provide a useful interface like a table calculation like
geometry input or a geometry orientated editor and transform this into the NEC Cards tables before feeding the kernel.
It is understood that the genius of computing the antenna properties lies at the employees of the Lawrence Livermoore
Laboratories that coded the NEC Kernels. But it is also understood that the genuis of providing a convenient human machine
interface lies at the makers of said antenna modelling software. As before that punchcards needed to be produced and
fed to crude computation machines. That is why NEC Cards are called NEC Cards. Because in the beginning they were
hard paper punchcards.
See More: DG7YBN / Ant.-Soft / Antenna Modelling Software
More
Yaesu FTDX10 Tuning and Receiver Deep Dive
Today I welcome Doug, N4HNH, from the YouTube channel N4HNH Radio, and we discuss the best receiver tuning practices for the new Yaesu FTDX10 HF Ham R... Read more
HF SDR Transceiver RS-918 mcHF
Here we take a look at the RS-918 HF SDR Transceiver, a typical clone of the mcHF. Specification: – HF QRP Transceiver,put battery 12v and ANT... Read more
To Choke or not to Choke?
Damian, VA3CYC, is working on building a copper pipe VHF antenna, and wants to know how he should do the chokes? How many? Is one ferrite choke equal... Read more
Wooden Satellite to Launch by Year’s End
The WISA Woodsat project, being sponsored by plywood supplier WISA in an unconventional PR initiative, is poised to place a wooden satellite into orbi... Read more
AlexLoop HamPack
This is the AlexLoop HamPack system – the ultimate solution for the hampacker and the antenna restricted Ham. Read more
Wimo X-Quad Antenna for 144 MHz 18010
The X-Quad antenna is a refinement of the well-known multi-element quads. Its special features, especially developed for amateur radio, are Switchable... Read more
NCDXF HF beacon monitoring station DL8LAS
Location: JO54EF , Trent, Germany, 54°20′ N 10°36′ E RX: IC-7851 ANT: 7m vertical omnidirectional homemade E... Read more
First Antenna Questions
Laurent Egli, soon to be HB9***, has some questions about what antenna would be a good first antenna for her. Read more
The VP2VB Danny Weil Memorial DXpedition is JIDXM 2020 DXpedition of the Year
The Japan International DX Meeting (JIDXM) has designated the 2020 VP2VB Danny Weil Memorial DXpedition as the recipient of the 2020 DXpedition of the... Read more
Over 50 km on 481 THz! Great news from SP
On May 8, 2021, the group of Polish radio amateurs: Marek SP4ELF, Jurek SP2GUB, Adam SQ2DOL, Piotr SQ4MIK, and Jarek SQ4IOB realized optical communica... Read more
R&S®M3SR Series4100 Software Defined Radios
Key facts Frequency range: 1.5 MHz to 30 MHz (transmission), 10 kHz to 30 MHz (reception) Power classes of 150 W, 500 W,... Read more
“Geomagnetic Storm Season” is Over
June and July bring frequent 6-meter DX openings via long-distance sporadic-E propagation and persistent quiet geomagnetic conditions. These 2 months... Read more
Comparing the lab599 Discovery TX-500 with the Elecraft KX2. Which one should you choose?
Comparing the lab599 Discovery TX-500 with the Elecraft KX2. Which one should you choose? Read more
The last Morse code maritime radio station in North America | Bartell’s Backroads
1999 marked the last time a commercial Morse code message was supposedly transmitted to ships at sea. However, if you travel on the backroads to Point... Read more
60 Meters Again Available to New Zealand Radio Amateurs
The New Zealand Association of Radio Transmitters (NZART) announced recently that negotiations with regulator RSM were successful in accommodating 60-... Read more
Warning: file_get_contents(https://plusone.google.com/_/+1/fastbutton?url=https%3A%2F%2Fqrznow.com%2Fdg7ybn-ant-soft-antenna-modelling-software%2F): failed to open stream: HTTP request failed! HTTP/1.0 404 Not Found in /home/qrznow/public_html/wp-content/themes/goodnews5/framework/functions/posts_share.php on line 151
