In comments filed on March 23 on its Petition for Rule Making (RM 11759) seeking changes to 80 and 75 meters, the ARRL has told the FCC that its primary objective is to “rebalance” the bands by correcting a 10-year old FCC error.
“ARRL’s proposal is not fairly viewed as a proposal to take anything away from anyone,” the League’s comments assured. “It is more properly viewed as the effectuation of a fair, equitable, and efficient ‘band plan’ looking forward for the foreseeable future that balances everyone’s needs, and which remedies a plainly unfair plan, imprudently created in the 2006 Report and Order in WT Docket 04-140.”
Prompting the League’s assurances were comments filed on the ARRL’s Petitionby a number of Amateur Extra class licensees, who felt that refarming 3600 to 3650 kHz for data modes could prove to be a disincentive to General licensees to upgrade. Others commenters saw it as an unfair spectrum grab. The ARRL noted that prior to 2006, the band was evenly divided between RTTY/data and phone/image subbands, with the RTTY/data subband extending from 3500 to 3750 kHz, and the phone/image subband extending from 3750 to 4000 kHz.
The 2006 FCC Report and Order “substantially altered” what the League called “this even division of emission types.” In outlining the history of the proceeding, the ARRL pointed out that the FCC’s Notice of Proposed Rulemaking in Docket 01-140 would have shifted the line between the 80 meter RTTY/data subband and the 75 meter phone/image subband from 3750 kHz to 3725 kHz, pursuant to a 2002 ARRL Petition for Rule Making, RM-10413. This would change the ratio of spectrum between phone/image and RTTY/data segments on 75/80 meters from 50/50 to 55/45, and it is what the FCC proposed in its NPRM.
In its Report and Order in Docket 04-140, however, the FCC made “a verysubstantial and unjustifiable departure” from what it had proposed in its NPRM, the ARRL recounted. The Commission expanded the phone/image subband at 75 meters to 3600-4000 kHz, and it reduced the 80 meter RTTY/data subband to 3500-3600 kHz, eliminating RTTY operation above 3600 kHz and changing “the entire dynamic of this band,” the League said.
The FCC had said in its proposal that no licensees would lose operating privileges. Nonetheless, the FCC’s phone band expansion reduced by 100 kHz the spectrum between 3500 and 4000 kHz that was previously available to General class licensees, while Advanced licensees lost 75 kHz. In an apparent FCC oversight, the Report and Order completely eliminated access by automatically controlled digital stations (ACDS) to 3620 to 3635 kHz. A subsequent FCC Report and order and Order on Reconsideration only made the situation worse by replacing the deleted ACDS segment with 3585-3600 kHz.
“It resulted in a sudden and severe dislocation of traffic-handling nets using telegraphy, without advance planning or notice,” the ARRL said. “It disaccommodated net participants with General and Advanced class licenses; and it worsened the effect of the overexpansion of the 75 meter phone/image subband.”
The result, the ARRL noted, has been “a shortfall in available RTTY/data spectrum on 80 meters” that has created a significant obstacle to narrowband digital data communications and experimentation. The League said its currentPetition “simply restores that which was disruputed in 2006 in error.”
In its comments, the League conceded that compromises are inevitable in managing a heavily used band like 75/80 meters, no matter the band planning approach. “Looking forward, it is necessary, in order to encourage experimentation with and expand the use of digital communication techniques, to rebalance the 75 and 80 meter subbands,” the ARRL concluded.
More
![ICOM IC-705 [ Japanese Video ]](https://qrznow.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/maxresdefault-1-3-265x168.jpg)
More
FTdx10 & FT-991A SSB Receiver Comparison
“My good friend Joel, KC4WZB, loaned me his brand new Yaesu FTdx10. When I say loaned, I mean he picked it up at Ham Radio Outlet and brought it... Read more
The K7RA Solar Update
Tad Cook, K7RA, Seattle, reports: Sunspot activity has shown steady but modest increases over the past 3 weeks, with average daily sunspot weekly aver... Read more
EI2KM in CQWW CW 2015 80m 4-square receive ant
http://hamradioireland.blogspot.com EI2KC operating the EI2KM call during CQWW CW 2015 on 80 metres. I had the pleasure of using a 4-square receive an... Read more
New release of PoC transceiver ICOM IP501H
Product name / Type name IP ADVANCED RADIO SYSTEM PoC Transceiver / IP501H Suggested retail price Open price Release date Release in mid-February 2017... Read more
Codan 2110M – HF Transceiver – Military
Frequency rangeTransmit: 1.6 to 30 MHz, 10 Hz steps Receive: 0.25 to 30 MHz, 10 Hz steps Frequency Stability: ±0.5 ppm from –30°C to +60... Read more
KP2/WE5DX Virgin Islands NA-106
Virgin Islands Jeffrey N5TIT informs DxCoffee Readers: “The East Mississippi Field Unit (WE5DX) will be will be be active from the lovely Virgin Islan... Read more
20M Vertical Dipole – Amazing Performance – T2LT Design
Here we take a look at building a simple 20M Vertical Dipole purely from RG58 Coax. Read more
Operating Remotely in the 2014 Ten-Meter RTTY Contest by Mark, K6UFO
Read great article from K6UFO and ND2T – Operating Remotely in the 2014 Ten-Meter RTTY Contest Read more
Emergency Preparedness Takes Center Stage for 2018 Simulated Emergency Test
Emergency Preparedness The 2018 ARRL Simulated Emergency Test (SET) is just ahead. The primary ARRL-sponsored national emergency exercise is designed... Read more
Field Day 2020 — A Time to Adapt
Many individuals and groups organizing events for Field Day 2020 have been contacting ARRL for guidance on how to adapt their planned activities in th... Read more
RT9K/0 – Dobrzhanskogo , AS-203
The expedition team continue their way to IOTA AS-203NEW. Follow their track here. Upon arriving Petropavlovsk-Kamchatsky the team will wait for a sh... Read more
Wouxun KG-UV9G GMRS Handheld from Better Safe Radio
The KG-UV9G Handheld GMRS Radio from Wouxun is a great addition to any GMRS line-up of radios The BSR-Exclusive Wouxun KG-UV9G is a 999 channel progra... Read more
Well-Known Contester and Contest Station Builder Grady Ferguson, W5FU, SK
A well-known contester and the co-builder of contest stations in Texas and Nevada, Grady Ferguson, W5FU (ex-NA5R), died of COVID-19 on July 14. He was... Read more
RufzXP is an excellent training software for improving code speed and CW practice
What is RufzXP ? “Rufz” is the abbreviation of the German word “Rufzeichen-Hören”, which means “Listening to Callsigns... Read more
CQ World Wide DX CW Announced Operations: 2015
Visit Below: CQ ZONE MAP´s Read more
Handheld Ailunce HD1 Retevis Dual Band DMR – Review
“Here is the Ailunce HD1, or what I call the Retevis HD1. It is a dual band, 10w/8w Handheld Analog and DMR, with GPS and IP67 waterproofing. A... Read more
HF Omniangles HF-28 ( 10 Meters )
HF Omniangles Our HF line of horizontal omnis are a bit different than the VHF and UHF models in that they aren’t as excellent from an omnidirec... Read more
![Apache Labs ANAN-8000DLE 200 watts SDR HF+6M [ Video Preview ]](https://qrznow.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/T500_1048_Small-8000DLE-Front-190x122.png)
Apache Labs ANAN-8000DLE 200 watts SDR HF+6M [ Video Preview ]
Apache Labs at Orlando Hamcation, introducing the ANAN-8000DLE 200 watt SDR, HF-6m The ANAN-8000DLE HF & 6M 200W SDR Transceiver meets and exceeds... Read more
Warning: file_get_contents(https://plusone.google.com/_/+1/fastbutton?url=https%3A%2F%2Fqrznow.com%2Farrl-tells-fcc-to-restore-balance-of-modes-on-80-and-75-meters%2F): failed to open stream: HTTP request failed! HTTP/1.0 404 Not Found in /home/qrznow/public_html/wp-content/themes/goodnews5/framework/functions/posts_share.php on line 151
