In comments filed on March 23 on its Petition for Rule Making (RM 11759) seeking changes to 80 and 75 meters, the ARRL has told the FCC that its primary objective is to “rebalance” the bands by correcting a 10-year old FCC error.
“ARRL’s proposal is not fairly viewed as a proposal to take anything away from anyone,” the League’s comments assured. “It is more properly viewed as the effectuation of a fair, equitable, and efficient ‘band plan’ looking forward for the foreseeable future that balances everyone’s needs, and which remedies a plainly unfair plan, imprudently created in the 2006 Report and Order in WT Docket 04-140.”
Prompting the League’s assurances were comments filed on the ARRL’s Petitionby a number of Amateur Extra class licensees, who felt that refarming 3600 to 3650 kHz for data modes could prove to be a disincentive to General licensees to upgrade. Others commenters saw it as an unfair spectrum grab. The ARRL noted that prior to 2006, the band was evenly divided between RTTY/data and phone/image subbands, with the RTTY/data subband extending from 3500 to 3750 kHz, and the phone/image subband extending from 3750 to 4000 kHz.
The 2006 FCC Report and Order “substantially altered” what the League called “this even division of emission types.” In outlining the history of the proceeding, the ARRL pointed out that the FCC’s Notice of Proposed Rulemaking in Docket 01-140 would have shifted the line between the 80 meter RTTY/data subband and the 75 meter phone/image subband from 3750 kHz to 3725 kHz, pursuant to a 2002 ARRL Petition for Rule Making, RM-10413. This would change the ratio of spectrum between phone/image and RTTY/data segments on 75/80 meters from 50/50 to 55/45, and it is what the FCC proposed in its NPRM.
In its Report and Order in Docket 04-140, however, the FCC made “a verysubstantial and unjustifiable departure” from what it had proposed in its NPRM, the ARRL recounted. The Commission expanded the phone/image subband at 75 meters to 3600-4000 kHz, and it reduced the 80 meter RTTY/data subband to 3500-3600 kHz, eliminating RTTY operation above 3600 kHz and changing “the entire dynamic of this band,” the League said.
The FCC had said in its proposal that no licensees would lose operating privileges. Nonetheless, the FCC’s phone band expansion reduced by 100 kHz the spectrum between 3500 and 4000 kHz that was previously available to General class licensees, while Advanced licensees lost 75 kHz. In an apparent FCC oversight, the Report and Order completely eliminated access by automatically controlled digital stations (ACDS) to 3620 to 3635 kHz. A subsequent FCC Report and order and Order on Reconsideration only made the situation worse by replacing the deleted ACDS segment with 3585-3600 kHz.
“It resulted in a sudden and severe dislocation of traffic-handling nets using telegraphy, without advance planning or notice,” the ARRL said. “It disaccommodated net participants with General and Advanced class licenses; and it worsened the effect of the overexpansion of the 75 meter phone/image subband.”
The result, the ARRL noted, has been “a shortfall in available RTTY/data spectrum on 80 meters” that has created a significant obstacle to narrowband digital data communications and experimentation. The League said its currentPetition “simply restores that which was disruputed in 2006 in error.”
In its comments, the League conceded that compromises are inevitable in managing a heavily used band like 75/80 meters, no matter the band planning approach. “Looking forward, it is necessary, in order to encourage experimentation with and expand the use of digital communication techniques, to rebalance the 75 and 80 meter subbands,” the ARRL concluded.
More
More
What makes a good portable CW paddle?
Richard G3CWI of SOTABEAMS has released a 3 minute video looking at the differences between a paddle designed for portable use and a fixed-station pad... Read more
Ailunce HS2 SDR Transceiver APP Control CW Transmit via Bluethooth
HS2 is an ultra-portable full-frequency full-mode SDR radio. Receive frequency coverage 300K~1.6GHZ. The built-in network port can realize remote oper... Read more
Chinese Amateur Radio Satellite Launches Delayed
CAMSAT says the CAS-7A launch has been postponed until next May, and CAS-5A until next June. “Because of COVID-19, many things have been delayed,” CAM... Read more
Acom 600S – 600W solid state 160m to 6m Amplifier
FEATURES • 5″ (108x65mm) high resolution color display, 800×480 pixels, and 24-bits colors. • The final stage uses field effect (MOSFET) tr... Read more
Geomagnetic Storms Likely on November 2-3
NOAA forecasters are predicting a 90 percent chance of geomagnetic storms today and tomorrow, when a fast-moving stream of solar wind is expected to h... Read more
4-Radio 8-Antenna Switch – Array Solutions
This compact system allows you to share up to 8 different antennas with 4 different radios. Perfect for Multi-Single, Multi-2, and some small M... Read more
Star Wars sound designer is, indeed, a radio enthusiast
SWLing Post readers may remember a post I recently published in which I believed I’d identified a familiar shortwave time signal station in the Battle... Read more
Well-Known Contester and Contest Station Builder Grady Ferguson, W5FU, SK
A well-known contester and the co-builder of contest stations in Texas and Nevada, Grady Ferguson, W5FU (ex-NA5R), died of COVID-19 on July 14. He was... Read more
LRN Precision LD-11 QRP Transceiver
LRN Precision LD-11 Transceiver Others state “extra”, We INCLUDE as STANDARD The HOTTEST new QRP Multimode HF+6M Transceiver on the marke... Read more
SPE 2K-FA Amplifier – ARRL Review
2 KW Solid State Fully Automatic Linear Amplifier The smallest in its class. Built-in Power supply and Automatic Antenna Tuner. Dimension: L 38, H 18.... Read more
![VHF / UHF Propagation [ ARRL The Doctor is In PodCast ]](https://qrznow.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/EFFOxd3XkAEqpMx-190x122.jpg)
Rotating Tower For Ham Radio 30 Feet Tall At Jim W6LG’s House And Can Be Used For Emergency Comms
“Jim Heath W6LG shows his newly installed antenna and tower at his residence. The tower has a maximum height of 30 feet as restricted by Placer... Read more
How to use Morse Code Keys – Demonstration by 10 year old
How to use Morse Code Keys Emilia giving small demonstration about how to use Morse Code Keys. At the end of the video she explains how our Mag... Read more
THREE TOWERS AWARD S.E.S. from San Marino
The Amateur Radio Association of the Republic of San Marino is happy to announce a special activity from the Three Towers of San Marino, a group of to... Read more
California QSO Party (CQP)
The California QSO Party (CQP) is held every year on the first weekend of October. The first CQP took place in 1966. Since 1974, the Northern Califor... Read more
HRN 190: CQ ‘Comes Clean’
Another tough year for CQ, and editor Rich Moseson W2VU talks to Gary about it, and the current state of the magazine. www.cq-amateur-radio.com ... Read more
Review of MFJ’s New Xiegu X5105 HF QRP Deluxo
Review of MFJ’s newest radio. MFJ is the sole importer of the new Xiegu X5105 160m-6m QRP SSB/CW/AM/FM radio with built in rechargeable battery... Read more
W1AW Operating Schedule
W1AW 6:45 pm 7:45 pm 8:45 pm 9:45 pm 0145z Voice Bulletin 7 pm 8 pm 9 pm 10 pm 0200z Fast Code Slow Code Fast Code Slow Code Fast Code 8 pm 9 pm 10 pm... Read more
Warning: file_get_contents(https://plusone.google.com/_/+1/fastbutton?url=https%3A%2F%2Fqrznow.com%2Farrl-tells-fcc-to-restore-balance-of-modes-on-80-and-75-meters%2F): failed to open stream: HTTP request failed! HTTP/1.0 404 Not Found in /home/qrznow/public_html/wp-content/themes/goodnews5/framework/functions/posts_share.php on line 151
