ARRL Comments in “Strong Opposition” to Part 15 Modification Petition Affecting 5 GHz

ARRL has commented in “strong opposition” to a Petition for Rulemaking by RADWIN Ltd. that seeks to amend certain Part 15 rules to permit point-to-multipoint (P2MP) communication services in portions of the 5 GHz band, at power levels now permitted only for point-to-point unlicensed systems. ARRL has focused its concern on proposed high-power P2MP operation in the band 5.725 – 5.850 MHz, but points out that the entire 5.650 – 5.925 GHz allocation has been “subjected to a continuing series of overlays domestically” for more than 2 decades. Amateur Radio is secondary to military radars on the band.

ARRL said the Amateur Radio national “weak-signal” calling frequency of 5.760.1 GHz already has experienced a “very substantial” rise in ambient noise in many areas that has significantly affected Amateur Radio operation in the 200 kHz centered on that frequency, where extremely weak received signal levels are typical. Only low-density usage and the low-power levels permitted for unlicensed national information infrastructure (U-NII) devices have sustained “a good deal of compatibility” between Amateur Radio and U-NII devices at 5 GHz, ARRL said.

“It is quite obvious that RADWIN’s proposal for simultaneous point-to-multipoint transmission, with higher input power and [effective isotropic radiated power (EIRP)], using an electronic steerable antenna system, presents an exceptionally high interference potential to ongoing, weak-signal Amateur Radio Service communications,” ARRL said in its comments filed on July 30. With users located “at all points of the compass from the distribution point,” ARRL said, the potential for interference to Amateur Radio “is much greater.” Greater yet, ARRL noted, is the potential of interference to users of RADWIN’s system.

ARRL said the FCC “has no idea at all” about aggregate noise levels in the 5 GHz band in general, while Amateur Radio and Amateur Satellite users have reported increased ambient noise levels in the band, especially near 5.760 GHz. “Both the Petition and the technical statement accompanying the Petition are silent on potential interaction between P2MP simultaneous transmission systems operating at high power, and any Amateur Radio facility,” ARRL said. “As a result, the petition is fatally flawed and should be dismissed, relative to the 5.725 – 5.850 GHz band.”

ARRL asserted that the FCC lacks jurisdiction to authorize Part 15 device operation by rule, “absent a specific finding that the device will not predictably cause interference.” Unlicensed, very low-power Part 15 devices may not cause interference to licensed services and must accept any interference caused by a licensed station and must shut down if notified by the FCC that the device is causing harmful interference.

ARRL said RADWIN’s Petition not only is flawed, but fails to address the issue of compatibility between the proposed high-power P2MP Part 15 operation and individual stations in incumbent primary and secondary services.

“It is long past time that petitioners such as RADWIN provide in their rulemaking petitions dealing with Part 15 rules enough data to allow the Commission to make an evaluation that fulfills its obligation under the Communications Act,” ARRL concluded. “RADWIN’s Petition must be dismissed as one which fails to provide an adequate justification for the relief requested.”

Source:ARRL

Antenna

6 el 50MHz LFA-R reflectorless Yagi

February 14, 2015 No comments

Description The new LFA-R reflector-less Yagi is a step forward in Yagi design and performance. Excellent levels of gain per foot of boom from this co... Read more

2 Meter Quad PVC Pipe Antenna by KG0ZZ

July 22, 2015 No comments

2 Meter Quad This is a different way of using PVC pipe to build a 2 meter cubical quad antenna. Instead of an “X” style spreader this ante... Read more

XR3: Compact 6 Element 20m/15m/10m Multi-Mono Contest Yagi

December 02, 2014 No comments

If your focus is the 20, 15 and 10 meter ‘Contest Bands,’ have limited antenna space and want the highest possible performan... Read more

X-Quad antennas for 2m and 70cm

September 25, 2017 No comments

Photo: EA5FUZ The X-Quad is an improved design of the well known multi element quads. They are especially designed for amateur radio, with the followi... Read more

“Antenna Wire” is the topic of the latest episode of the “ARRL The Doctor is In”

January 18, 2018 No comments

“Antenna Wire” is the topic of the latest (January 18) episode of the “ARRL The Doctor is In” podcast. Listen…and learn! More than a half-mill... Read more

Review

Retevis Ailunce HD1 GPS dual band 2m 70cm DMR [ Review and Teardown ]

September 21, 2018 No comments

Ailunce HD1 Dual Band DMR Amateur Digital Radio Almost all the operations can be done via radio keypad. Dual Band DMR Radio,Analog and Digital Comb... Read more

Output Power vs. S-Units

April 27, 2019 No comments

“This is one of the most important concepts in ham radio… the relationship between transmitted power and received signal strength. Sadly,... Read more

CS-580 DMR Radio Review and a big announcement

December 06, 2017 No comments

CS-580 DMR Radio The CS580 is one of our most exciting new products that we have designed in the past 30 years. This DMR radio is designed specificall... Read more

Baofeng BF-F8HP Dual Band UHF/VHF – 8 Watt output [ Video ]

July 11, 2015 No comments

Baofeng BF-F8HP Read more

Overview of the Kenwood TH-D74A

September 26, 2018 No comments

Kenwood TH-D74A 144/220/430 MHz TRIBANDER. Triband Amateur radio packed with convenient features and the advantage of a digital transceiver with D-STA... Read more

VHF

YANTON DM-980

August 13, 2015 No comments

YANTON DM-980 Built for dual-mode (Digital+ Analog) 1000Channels Versatile Voice Call (Private call,group call, all call and emergency call) Digital e... Read more

Small APRS Transceiver with MicroAPRS by DB1NTO

December 17, 2014 No comments

Small APRS Transceiver with MicroAPRS by DB1NTO Read full Article from DB1NTO : Read more

Alinco DJ-MD5T VHF/UHF 5W DMR HT

May 18, 2018 No comments

Alinco DJ-MD5T VHF/UHF 5W DMR DUal Mode Tier I/II HT Features: DMR Tier I and Tier II 1.77 inch TFT color LCD VFO/MR Switch Output Power Selection (5W... Read more

Maidenhead Grid Square Locator System – Ham Radio Q&A

May 31, 2017 No comments

“You’ve seen these printed on QSO cards, but what do they mean. I’m talking about grid squares, a unique method of geolocation that is popular w... Read more

Baofeng DM-1801 digital dual-channel walkie-talkie DMR Tier1 Tier2 Tier II Dual time slot digital radio Compatible with Motorola DM-860

December 15, 2018 No comments

Baofeng DM-1801 Baofeng DM-860 Dual Band Dual Time DMR slot digital / analog two way radio 136-174 / 400-470 MHz 1024 Channels Ham Walkie Talkie.1. Ba... Read more